Restaurant Recommendations

a bottle of wine and a wine glass
Water Street, 508-627-3761 (Reservations Accepted)
(Date Night / Adults No Kids / Expensive)
North Water Street (in the Harbor View Hotel, downtown Edgartown).
A perfect place for a little bit of dressing up, and enjoying fine food.

Chesca’s, 508-627-1234 (Reservations for Parties of 6+)
(Nice and older Kid Friendly)
38 North Water Street (in the Colonial Inn, downtown Edgartown).
A bit loud, but great, mostly Italian and seafood place.

Beach Plum Inn Restaurant 508-645-9454 (Reservations Accepted)
(Date Night/Adult/Expensive)
12 Menemsha Inn Road
(the official address, call the restaurant for real directions)
One of our very favorite places on earth, the sunsets over the water are unbelievable. Beautiful, romantic, perfect. The food is farm-to-table and ocean-to-table fresh. This is out of the way in Chilmark, so get directions from the restaurant, bring your GPS, and leave extra early. But if you want a special experience, this is it.

1. If you are on the island in August, make reservations ahead of time or be prepared to eat late or wait.
2. While there IS take out/pick up, there is no pizza delivery to Katama.